Skip to content

#BaltimoreUprising: Freddie Grey and the Future of America

May 2, 2015

by Karsonya Wise Whitehead

copyright May 1, 2015


I believe in the idea of the good. I believe that good people working together can bring about change. I believe that good things can happen even when you least expect them. I believe that good ideas once spoken become a part of our collective consciousness. I believe that good people working together can fix a myriad of problems. I believe that the most revolutionary job in the world, outside of being a teacher, is to be a change agent. I believe that good work—work that you can build upon, stand on, and stand behind—is both necessary and hard to do. I believe in the idea of the good and this is why I work for justice even though I understand that it may never happen.

     When I first watched the Freddie Grey video, I was stunned not because I thought that things like this did not happen but because I realized—in this climate of #BlackLivesMatter—that it was still happening. I spent countless nights thinking about Grey and his life and how the system just needs to be fixed. I traveled up to his neighborhood and listened to his friends and family members testify about their lives and about the daily challenges that come with being black and poor in America. I attended marches and rallies, took pictures and recorded oral interviews.  It was not until I interviewed a young boy—who told me that no matter what he does or where he goes, he is still black in America and he is still a target—that I sadly realized the problem with my thinking. I had always assumed that the system was broken and that hard work and good people would change it. I now understand that our system is not broken. It is working exactly as it was designed to work


photo courtesy of @mmmmmrtha

photo courtesy of @mmmmmrtha


In the mid-1600s, as American slavery began to take root, the system began a slow process of dehumanizing and criminalizing the black body. This was something that had to happen so that this brutal inhumane system could function. White people had to be complicit and they had to believe that black people were less than human. They had to buy into the system. America began to transform itself from a nation with slaves (where slavery was a part of the economic system) into a slave nation (where slavery drove the economic system). The system was working. This peculiar institution lasted close to 200 years and allowed this country and slave owners to economically grow and develop at an almost unheard of pace. As the colonies begin to expand and state lines were being drawn, slavery continued to flourish and grow. As the Revolutionary War raged on and our founding fathers and mothers (many of them large-scale slaveholders) fought for freedom from the British, slavery—like a mustard seed—sank deep into our soil and became one of the cornerstones of our political, economic, and social system. At the same time as literacy rates begin to climb as more white children were taught to read, laws were established that made it illegal to teach a black person to read or write. As the nation promoted the idea of the strength of the white family, black couples who were unable to marry were routinely separated from their children and from their chosen partners. They were absolutely voiceless and considered as three-fifths of a human for tax purposes. The system worked because it kept black people completely controlled, by seeing them as animals and putting policies in place that treated them as such.

When slavery ended and the system could have changed, Jim Crow was established and slavery by another name continued to exist. There were no reparations and formerly enslaved black people, without property or land, education or resources, had to find a way to slowly build their communities. The system, the one that had enslaved them for hundreds of years, gave them nothing and in so many ways, believed that they did not deserve anything. Legalized segregation borne out of this idea that black people are inferior to white people lasted for 77 years and drove housing policies, community development, voting practices, and school funding. This law did not end until some Americans were willing to die to force it to change and when it finally did and policies changed, the system—at its core—did not. Black people were and are still dehumanized, still criminalized, and still trying to prove to this world that our lives matter.



     In Baltimore City, as in many urban cities, black people have the highest rates of unemployment, the lowest rates of literacy, the highest number of high school dropouts, and they tend to live in low-income underdeveloped food deserts. Martin Luther King, Jr. once said that our system must be completely restructured and we must realize that “the problem of racism, the problem of economic exploitation, and the problem of war are all tied together.” These are complicated issues and the only way that they can be changed is for the current system to be dismantled. It is inhumane. It is racist and sexist and classist. It enslaves us all but it is not broken. It is working.

4 Comments leave one →
  1. May 2, 2015 1:27 am

    Absolutely beautifully articulated, thoughtful, compelling–with the promise of redemption and societal cleansing of all that burdens us, shackles us still. I do feel a sense of hope, rebirth even. Thank you. Jim

    • May 2, 2015 4:51 am

      Dear Jim:
      Thank you for your comments and for taking the time to read my blog.

  2. Ryan Dupee permalink
    May 2, 2015 2:58 am

    Dr. Whitehead,

    I am amazed and applaud the fervency in which you serve and seek to change the larger community and context of social change. You are certainly a model citizen when speaking in the area of social justice and an agent of change in the world and community around you.

    As one who claims Christ and the ultimate goal of humanity to glorify Christ, I am surprised by your first paragraph. You say you believe in good–then you must connect that to the character of God, for man’s heart is desperately wicked, and all of our good or righteousness is as filthy rags.

    Second, you stated that you believe good things happened to good people. This, once again, is not true. Throughout humanity, there are many examples of people who were inherently good–even followers of Christ, who have been martyred by those who have hated them for their confession in God. The recent martyrdom of Christians around the world is in direct conflict with this statement because sinners are going to sin and people will destroy people for many different causes, including racism, which is an issue for all skin colors and ethnicities.

    Third, you state that good ideas become part of our consciousnesses. If God is only good, then He is the only giver of the model of what is true and that which leads to a truly happy life. And yet we, humanity, have chosen to not retain God in our thoughts. In my limited and unworthy opinion, once again a flawed premise for TRUE change.

    Finally, people working together cannot fix a problem unless their thinking has been fixed. If we truly want change, we desire the truth which changes us.

    Knowing that you believe in God, I would beg of you to use this incredible platform for the change that can truly change the individual–the gospel of Jesus Christ, which knows no color or racial boundaries and presents us with the opportunity for change that can renew a nation that truly is under God.

    Submitted with prayer for the people of Baltimore, and a nation that truly needs heart change to experience true justice.

    • May 2, 2015 4:58 am

      Dear Ryan:
      Thank you for your comments. Unfortunately, due to an editing error the unedited version was uploaded. At the same time, I do appreciate how quickly you read and responded to it. Your comments are duly noted. I was using the notion of the idea of the good to describe a system that is uniquely situated for change as described by Plato. I did see, after you pointed it out, that my mnemonic device of believing in the good could lead someone to think that I believed in the good over God. I did make some edits to further clarify my points.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: